Findings

• All 1420 offspring samples contained enough DNA to successfully amplify 7 – 13 loci and 1208 samples were unique. Only predated eggshell fragments resulted in duplicates of one another. 

• We found all offspring matched their putative mothers with the exception of 26 eggs found in 10 clutches that were the result of intraspecific nest parasitism.

 • Thirty-six sampled males were identified as fathers (24 captured males, 10 males sampled via molted feathers, and two males sampled as offspring in previous years; age 2 and 3 when they fathered offspring). These 36 males fathered completely, or in part, 63 (33.2%) of the sampled clutches. Unsampled males fathered the remaining clutches (n = 127, 66.8%). The most clutches that any given male fathered during the course of the study was seven (one male) over three years and the most fathered in a given year was three (n = 5 males). Nine unsampled males fathered more than one clutch. None of the known males that fathered offspring were yearlings. Of the 34 males with known lek affiliations, nine sired offspring of females never observed attending their lek.  In two of these instances, females were observed on the closest neighboring lek to where males were displaying, but in one case, the female was only observed on a lek 54 km away. Thirteen of 14 males that fathered multiple clutches mated with females that were observed to attend the leks on which these males displayed. 

• Percentage of genetically identified males in the population fathering offspring in a given year ranged from 14.3 to 54.5%, with an overall average of 45.9%

• Of the 191 clutches, 169 (88.5%) had a single father, 13 (6.8%) had two fathers, seven (3.7%) were a mix of eggs belonging to the putative mother with a single father and dumped eggs (single paternity in both clutches), one (0.5%) had two fathers of different species (sage-grouse and sharp-tailed grouse [Tympanuchus phasianellus jamesi]), and one (0.5%) was a mix of eggs belonging to the putative mother with two fathers and dumped eggs with single paternity.

• One hundred and thirty offspring (10.8%) came from clutches with multiple fathers. In clutches with two fathers, paternity by individual males ranged from 11 to 89%.

• Of the 1206 eggs, 574 (47.6%) successfully hatched. One-hundred and four females laid 191 clutches. Each female produced between one and six clutches with a maximum of 44 offspring and 32 successful offspring. Twenty-four females laid two sampled clutches in a single year, with most of these clutches fathered by two different males. Thirty-seven females laid two or more clutches over their sampled lifetime, with most of clutches singly fathered by different males.

ª Opportunity for selection - We found that the opportunity for selection was higher among males than females and was generally highest when measured in terms of successful (hatched) offspring. We calculated IM for behavioral studies that published raw copulation data (how many times every male on a lek(s) bred over a season) for sage-grouse across the species’ range and compared these values to our clutch values (IM  = 3.9). Annual IM was high for large leks in southeastern Wyoming (8.7 – 20.3; Wiley 1973), central Wyoming (6.8 – 16.2; G. L. Patricelli and A. H. Krakauer, unpubl. data) and Montana (6.0; Lumsden 1968). IM was considerably lower in California (3.0; R. M. Gibson pers. comm.), Alberta (5.1; J. Carpenter, unpubl. data) and for Gunnison sage-grouse in Colorado (annual IM = 2.9 – 9.9; J. Stiver, unpubl. data). 
 

Conservation Implications

Despite their small numbers and restricted habitat, sage-grouse in Alberta are genetically diverse and do not exhibit evidence of inbreeding. We have previously found that this is partly due to high levels of gene flow from other parts of the northern Montana population (the population to which they belong [Alberta, Saskatchewan, and northern Montana]), but this study provides further evidence for why the birds are genetically diverse. If sage-grouse leks in Alberta functioned as previously thought, with only a few males obtaining most of the copulations (Wiley 1973), genetic drift would be accelerated due to a small effective population size. Instead, it appears a large subset of males breed at least once during their lifespan, with only a few males being more successful. This pattern causes genetic diversity to be lost at a slower rate from the population. Alternatively, because the habitat available in Alberta is so small and suboptimal naturally and due to fragmentation, high rates of male influx and turnover may have led to reduced opportunity for polygyny. Sage-grouse in Alberta currently exhibit both gene flow and reduced variance in reproductive success, but if gene flow from the rest of the population stops or usable habitat is further reduced, sage-grouse will not be able to sustain current genetic diversity levels for long. Therefore, the landscape needs to be managed to maintain connectivity. We also need to determine where unsampled males breed (on lek, off-lek, or unsampled/unknown leks). Leks are the primary focus of current sage-grouse conservation because they are the mating and nesting hubs for the species (Connelly et al. 2004), but if mating occurs off-lek and birds move great distances between leks to select a mate, a broader-based, less lek-centric approach to habitat conservation should be adopted.

Contact Me ~ All Pictures are Copyrighted to Dr. Krissy Bird ~ Last Updated August 31, 2011